This text was printed from the Women Film Pioneers Project at Columbia University.
To promote readability and conserve consumable resources, images and interactive elements in the digital version do not appear in print format.
Please visit https://wfpp.cdrs.columbia.edu/pioneer/ccp-ruth-ann-baldwin/ to see the complete version.
Credits do not record some of the most significant accomplishments of Baldwin’s amazing decade. In January 1915, for instance, Universal dispatched her to London to collaborate with mystery novelist E. Phillips Oppenheim on The Black Box serial. A press book for the serial’s British release explained: “the author, realising that with all his brilliance as a novelist, it was necessary to consult someone with a complete knowledge of the technical side of film manufacture in order to get the best possible results, was more than glad to have Miss Baldwin’s valuable aid.” Given that serials were among the most costly productions at that time and that Oppenheim had no prior experience writing for motion pictures, the appointment testifies to Universal’s confidence in Baldwin’s ability.
Universal’s house organ, then called the Moving Picture Weekly, provides in an article titled “Another Woman Directing,” another glimpse behind the scenes when it reports that, as part of her apprenticeship as a director, Baldwin assisted Reynolds in the production of The End of the Rainbow (1916) (23). In this feature, Myrtle Gonzalez stars as the business-school educated daughter of a timber baron who, defying her father’s interdiction, goes undercover as a stenographer to investigate corruption in his logging camp. Although the extent of Baldwin’s contribution to this film will likely never be known, a print does survive. Shot on location in a redwood forest near Hume, California, the film stands out for its amazing scenery, snappy cross-cutting, Gonzalez’s take-charge heroine, and a proto-environmentalist subplot involving the male lead’s sentimental attachment to “Old Sentinel”—a particularly ancient redwood that ultimately succumbs to the villains’ saws and axes.
Baldwin directed and typically also adapted the scenario for a variety of dramas. Timed for a Thanksgiving release, her directorial debut, The Mother Call (1916) tells in one reel the story of an elderly mother who feels abandoned by her children and is delighted when they show up for the holiday, according to the November 18, 1916, issue of the Moving Picture Weekly (23). A dozen films followed in 1917. In The Rented Man (1917), a young boy hires a boarder to play the part of his missing father only to discover that the “rented man” is his real parent. The Black Mantilla (1917) narrates a tragic love story set in Mexico. Two shorts employ a framing story: in A Soldier of the Legion (1917), boarding house residents concoct an Algerian fable; in The Storm Woman (1917) an old man’s tale of a fatal love triangle involving a New York playboy and two Italian sisters has a surprise happy ending. Baldwin’s first feature, A Wife on Trial (1917), depicts a woman librarian who marries a moody paralytic in order to be near to his wealthy family’s rose garden. In the final reel, this marriage of convenience gives way to true love, according to a synopsis in Moving Picture Weekly (30). Although difficult to appraise in the absence of surviving prints, Baldwin’s oeuvre suggests an interest in problems of narrative construction, and reviews on both sides of the Atlantic emphasized the novelty of the plots as well as the manner of treating them on screen, as in, for instance, the British trade paper Bioscope review of The Girl Who Married (1917). The beauty and exoticism of the settings of these films are also frequently noted.
A keen awareness of narrative convention as well as a wry perspective on the motion picture business comes across in Baldwin’s surviving feature,’49-’17 (1917). A Western genre parody, the film stars Baldwin’s husband Leo O. Pierson as a city man hired to recreate a Western town for his boss, Judge Brand, who wants to relive his glory days as a miner “Forty-Niner.” He hires actors, but some members of the troupe turn out to be figures from Brand’s past. Western fun turns dangerous when a backstory involving a love triangle, an attempted murder, and a gold mine comes to light. It all works out in the end, however, and Pierson’s character earns his spurs and “gets the girl,” played by Donna Drew. The parodic doubling of the plot, in which actors portray actors who turn out to be “real Westerners,” that is, stereotypical figures from Western films, takes on an ironic cast when one recalls that some of Baldwin’s Universal contemporaries were building reputations by taking the genre far more seriously. Less than two months before ’49-’17, for example, Universal had released Straight Shooting (1917), the first Western feature directed by Maine native John Ford, staring New Yorker Harry Carrey. The historical record might never reveal whether Baldwin intended to deflate or celebrate the spectacle of grown Eastern men playing at being cowboys. Her film, however, leaves little doubt that we are to regard it as a form of playacting.
The ‘Black Box’ Pressbook. BFI-SC.
Carr, Harry. “The Lancer.” Los Angeles Times (8 Dec. 1925): A1.
“Claire McDowell in ‘The Black Mantilla’.” Moving Picture Weekly (9 June 1917): 9.
“Doings at Universal City.” Moving Picture Weekly (13 Jan. 1917): 22-23.
“The Girl Who Married-a Rose Garden.” Rev. Bioscope (18 Oct. 1917): 49.
“Irene Hunt in ‘A Soldier of the Legion’.” Moving Picture Weekly (21 July 1917): 28-29.
“Mignon Anderson and Leo Pierson in 'a Wife on Trial.'” Moving Picture Weekly (21 July 1917): 30-31.
“Miss Ruth Ann Baldwin Sails for Europe.” Moving Picture Word (9 Jan. 1915): 197.
Motion Picture Studio Directory and Trade Annual 1920. New York: Motion Picture News Inc, 1920.
“The Rented Man.” Synopsis. Moving Picture Weekly (24 Feb. 1917): 16.
Rothschild, Herbert. “Two Universal Thanksgiving Offerings.”Moving Picture Weekly (18 Nov. 1916): 1, 23.
“The Storm Woman.” Synopsis. Moving Picture Weekly (22 Sep. 1917): 9, 39.
U.S. Census 1900. Census Place: San Diego Ward 2, San Diego, California. Roll T623_99, Page 2A, Enumeration District 190.
U.S. Census 1920. Census Place: Los Angeles, California. Roll T625_107, Page 17A, Enumeration District 180.
Archival Paper Collections:
Ruth Ann Baldwin clippings file. AMPAS-SC.
The Black Box Pressbook. BFI-SC.Complete Project Bibliographies
A. Archival Filmography: Extant Film Titles:
1. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Screenwriter
Damon and Pythias. Dir. Otis Turner, sc.: James Dayton, Ruth Ann Baldwin (Universal Film Mfg. Co. US 1914) cas.: William Worthington, Herbert Rawlinson, Cleo Madison, Anna Little, Frank Floyd, Helen Wright. si, b&w, 35mm, 5 reels. Archive: USW, USR, NLA.
2. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Assistant Director
The End of the Rainbow. Dir./sc.: Lynn F. Reynolds, asst. dir.: Ruth Ann Baldwin (Bluebird Photoplays, Inc. US 1916) cas.: Myrtle Gonzales, George Hernandez, Val Paul, Jack Curtis, Fred Church, Joseph Ryan, Jack Connolly, si, b&w, 35mm, 5 reels. Archive: USW, USM.
3. Ruth Ann Baldwin Director and Screenwriter
’49-’17/Old West Per Contract. Dir./sc.: Ruth Ann Baldwin (Butterfly Picture/Universal Film Mfg. Co. US 1917) cas.: Jean Hersholt, Joseph W Girard, Leo Pierson, Mrs. A. E. Witting, Harry Rattenberry, George Pearce, si, b&w, 35mm, 5 reels. Archive: USW.
B. Filmography: Not Extant Titles:
1. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Director
The Mother Call 1916; Three Women of France, 1917; A Wife on Trial, 1917.
2. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Director/Screenwriter
The Black Mantilla, 1917; Is Money All, 1917; The Rented Man, 1917; The Storm Woman, 1917; Twixt Love and Desires, 1917. When Liz Lets Loose, 1917; The Woman Who Would Not Pay, 1917.
3. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Director and Co-Screenwriter
It Makes a Difference, 1917; A Soldier of the Legion, 1917.
4. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Source Author
The Werewolf, 1913 ; The Big Sister’s Christmas, 1914; The Blank Page, 1915; A Double Deal in Pork. 1915; Pawns of Fate, 1915; The Mother Call, 1916; Traffic in Babies, 1914.
5. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Screenwriter
The Prince of Bavaria, 1914; Traffic in Babies, 1914; Vagabond, 1914; An Arrangement with Fate, 1915; A Recoiling Vengeance, 1916; Chasing Rainbows, 1919; Cheating Herself/The Bed She Made, 1919; The Sneak, 1920; The Devil’s Riddle, 1921; The Marriage of William Ashe, 1921.
6. Ruth Ann Baldwin as Co-Screenwriter
The Black Box, 1915; Puppets of Fate, 1921.
C. DVD/VHS Sources:
First Ladies: Early Women Filmmakers. DVD. (Kino Lorber US 2008)- contains 49-’17 (1917).
Pioneers: First Women Filmmakers. DVD/Blu-ray. (Kino Lorber US 2018 - contains 49-'17 (1917)
49-'17 (1917) is streaming online via Kanopy
Ruth Ann Baldwin is uncredited for her work as the assistant director of The End of the Rainbow (1916). She may or may not have directed The Girl who Married (1917).